Property-Backed vs. Regular P2P: Which Strategy Fits Your Portfolio?

When you first dive into the world of Peer-to-Peer (P2P) investing, everything looks somewhat similar: you lend money, you get paid interest.

But not all loans are created equal. In fact, the difference between funding a consumer loan (Regular P2P) and a real estate loan (Property-Backed P2P) is as stark as the difference between buying a stock and buying a house.

To build a resilient portfolio, you need to understand the mechanics of both. Here is the definitive breakdown of Property-Backed vs. Regular P2P investing.

1. Regular P2P: The “High Volume” Game

What it is: “Regular” P2P usually refers to unsecured consumer loans (payday loans, car loans, or short-term installment loans). Platforms like Monefit, Maclear, or Lendermarket specialize in this. You are essentially acting as the bank for someone who needs €500 to fix their car or buy a new fridge.

The Mechanics:

Security: Most of these loans are unsecured. The borrower puts up no collateral.
The Safety Net: To protect investors, platforms often use a “Buyback Obligation.” If the borrower doesn’t pay for 60 days, the lending company (the Loan Originator) steps in and pays you back the principal and interest.
Duration: Very short. Loans can range from 30 days to 12 months.
Yield: Typically higher (10% – 14% APY).

The Risk: The risk here is Platform/Originator Counterparty Risk. Since the loans are unsecured, your safety depends entirely on the financial health of the lending company. If the company goes bankrupt, the “Buyback Obligation” is worthless, and you are left with bad debt.

2. Property-Backed P2P: The “Hard Asset” Game

What it is: This is often called Real Estate Crowdfunding (platforms like Fintown or Estateguru). Here, you aren’t lending to Joe for a fridge; you are lending to a property developer who needs €200,000 to build a row of houses or renovate an apartment building.

The Mechanics:

Security: These loans are secured by a mortgage. The property itself acts as collateral.
First Rank vs. Second Rank:
First Rank: You are first in line to get paid if the property is sold.
Second Rank: You get paid only after the bank (or senior lender) is paid.
Duration: Longer term. Projects usually last 12 to 36 months.
Yield: Moderate to High (8% – 12% APY).

The Risk: The risk here is Liquidity and Valuation. If a developer defaults, there is no automatic “Buyback.” The platform must go through a legal foreclosure process to sell the property. This takes time (often 1-2 years). Furthermore, if the real estate market crashes, the property might sell for less than the loan amount, leading to a loss of principal.

Key Differences at a Glance

Feature	Regular P2P (Consumer)	Property-Backed P2P (Real Estate)
Collateral	None (Unsecured)	Physical Real Estate (Mortgage)
Protection	Buyback Obligation (Corporate Guarantee)	Asset Value (LTV – Loan to Value)
Timeframe	Short (1 – 12 months)	Medium/Long (12 – 36 months)
Liquidity	High (Fast turnover)	Low (Locked in until project ends)
Main Risk	Loan Originator Bankruptcy	Project Failure / Market Crash

Which One Is Better?

Neither is “better,” but they serve different roles in your portfolio.

Choose Regular P2P if:

You want cash flow. The short-term nature means money is constantly being repaid and can be withdrawn easily.
You want high diversification. You can easily split €1,000 across 100 different consumer loans.
You trust the track record of the loan originators.

Choose Property-Backed P2P if:

You want security. You sleep better knowing there is a physical building backing your investment, not just a company’s promise.
You are a long-term investor. You don’t need the money for a year or two.
You want protection against inflation. Real estate values generally track with inflation over time.

The Verdict: The Hybrid Approach

The smartest investors don’t choose sides—they mix them.

A balanced P2P portfolio might look like this:

60% in Property-Backed Loans: To provide a stable, secured foundation with lower volatility.
40% in Regular P2P: To boost the overall yield and provide liquidity (cash flow) while the property loans are maturing.

By combining the “Buyback” speed of consumer loans with the “Mortgage” security of real estate, you build a portfolio that can survive both corporate bankruptcies and real estate downturns.

Start investing

Disclaimer: This blog post is for informational purposes only and does not constitute financial or investment advice. All investments carry risk, including the potential loss of principal. You should consult with a qualified financial professional before making any investment decisions.